In the early days of Toronto FC, the club struggled with an image problem. After the 2007 season when it became clear that the club, while dreadful on the pitch, was a success in the stands at BMO Field, with twenty-thousand supporters singing in full voice throughout each home match, certain media types made the kind of careless connection that certain media types sometimes make.

It went like this: The soccer fans in the stands at BMO were boisterous, much in the same way that fans in European stadiums were boisterous. There have been incidents of violent hooliganism in parts of Europe, ergo, Toronto was at risk of being overtaken by the soccer mob, as if the sport was some sort of disease.

Sometimes the connection was implied, particularly in 2009 when a TFC fan was tasered in Columbus and a well-known Toronto tabloid took the bait and ran with it, implying TFC fans were unruly. Sometimes it was explicit, as in Leah McLaren’s article on soccer “hooliganism”—which comprised some young men singing in public and a broken glass bar fight—for the Globe and Mail back in 2008.

Today, most papers are more concerned with TFC’s form on the pitch than the threat of the city going into an Inner City Firm meltdown. Perhaps this has been helped along by the growing realization that hockey, Canada’s sport, is also not completely immune from the vices that have gripped certain quarters in European soccer.

First, there was the Vancouver Stanley Cup riot this past June, which shocked the entire country. And, appallingly, yesterday a fan threw a banana at Philadelphia Flyers winger Wayne Simmonds, who is black.

It cannot be stressed enough—this likely involved a single fan out of thousands, so should not be used as means for blanket condemnation of hockey fans or the sport in general (Andrew Thomas wrote a good piece on this a month back). But it isn’t unprecedented in hockey, a league that features several prominent African Canadian players.  The incident is a reminder that while hockey is miles away from the kind of crowd racism or hooligan violence we sometimes see in parts of Europe, no sport is immune from the ugliness of the mob or the bigotry of individual fans.

Comments (4)

  1. To play Devli’s advocate, how about this scenario: The fan in question likes to eat bananas and is dismayed about buying expensive arena snacks. He believed he had brought a ripe banana to the arena, but was very disappointed that it was rotten/bruised. He threw it away in disgust and it happened to fall in the direction of Wayne Simmonds.

    Sound plausible? Anyone? Probably not, I know, but tell me that this doesn’t sound like an episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm.

  2. Inner City Firm=INTER City Firm? Never heard of the former..

  3. Wish some research was done. Simmonds played his junior hockey in Owen Sound and regularly came in and did damage to the local Knights junior squad.

    Racist act? Absolutely. But would be nice to know the background details to this act.

    As usual, Whittall merely skimming the surface, mistakenly believing that quantity, however low in standard, makes up for lack of quality.

    You’re no Gare Joyce, Sunshine.

    • Flashman – again, this tidbit you’ve mentioned doesn’t add anything here. You yourself acknowledge the racism inherent in the gesture; does the fact that Simmonds, like many, many future NHL stars, regularly featured against the Knights change anything?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *