The AFC North was the only division last season to send three teams to the playoffs. The Ravens, Steelers, and Bengals scrapped it out, with Baltimore ultimately winning the division with a 12-4 record, while Pittsburgh and Cincinnati secured wildcard spots. Cincinnati’s five-win improvement in one year has a lot of people talking about the Bengals heading into this season, but oddsmakers still believe that Cincinnati is a step behind Pittsburgh and Baltimore, as seen in the odds comparison below.

The Steelers and Ravens are in a dead heat in odds, with different sportsbooks listing different favorites for the division, while the Bengals implied probability is roughly 20 percent.The 35/1 odds being offered at most sportsbooks are nowhere near enough to warrant a bet on the Browns. Cleveland is just downright bad. Even if Brandon Weeden and Trent Richardson become elite talents in their first year, their schedule is so ridiculously difficult that they’d be lucky to finish 8-8, which isn’t going to cut it in the AFC North. The Browns open their season in order against the Eagles, Bengals, Bills, Ravens, and Giants. Best case scenario is that they win two of those games, and even that’s a huge stretch. The combination of a complete lack of talent and a difficult schedule will see the Browns in the mix for the first overall pick in next year’s NFL Draft.

The real question in the AFC North is whether or not the Bengals can give the “Big Two” a realistic push for the division crown, and I’m of the opinion that they won’t. There are simply too many question marks surrounding the Bengals, and it starts at the quarterback position.

I’m not quite sure why the general population is infatuated with Andy Dalton, who proved to be a serviceable quarterback in his rookie campaign, but contrary to popular belief, he was nothing more than that. In 17 games last season (including Cincy’s playoff game @ HOU), Dalton posted a quarterback rating above 100 only four times, while also posting an overall completion percentage under 59 percent. Those are simply aren’t playoff caliber numbers.

The only reason that the Bengals actually made it to the postseason last year is because they feasted on one of the NFL’s easiest schedules. In fact, none of Cincinnati’s nine wins in 2011 came against a team that qualified for the playoffs. I think that an implied probability of 20 percent to win the division is a reach for this Bengals team. There are certainly a number of talented players on their roster, but I think that this season for Cincinnati is more likely to be a regression than a progression.

The AFC North looks to be a two horse race between the Steelers and the Ravens once again in 2012, and for most people, trying to separate these two teams is nearly impossible. Both teams are fairly evenly matched, but there are a couple of factors that lead me to believe that Pittsburgh has a slight edge over Baltimore.

The first and most obvious factor is the injury to Ravens’ outside linebacker Terrell Suggs, who tore his Achilles in early April and will be sidelined for at the majority of the season. That’s 14 sacks and seven forced fumbles from last season that the Ravens won’t have on the field this year. Paul Kruger is a capable replacement at outside linebacker, but he undoubtedly will not be able to match the production of Suggs, and that will ultimately be a huge blow to the Baltimore defense, especially when you consider that the production of aging veterans Ray Lewis and Ed Reed is likely to drop off as well. On the other side of the ball, I’m not quite sold on the self-proclaimed top five quarterback Joe Flacco, but he did lead the Ravens to 12 wins last season, and put a ball in Lee Evans’ hands that would have had the Ravens representing the AFC in the Super Bowl.

Aside from the concerns that I mentioned above, Baltimore is solid all around. The biggest issue I have with the Ravens has nothing to do with personnel—it’s their ridiculously difficult schedule. Other than a couple of probable wins against the Browns, the Ravens don’t have another game that you could mark down as a win on their schedule.

Pittsburgh, on the basis of finishing second in the division last season, still gets stuck with a difficult schedule, but benefits from getting to avoid games against New England and Houston. In a division that’s likely to be scratch and claw until the end of the season, the Steelers really luck out by dodging those tough games. In addition to their slightly easier schedule, I feel that Pittsburgh will get a boost in an area that was their biggest weakness last season: their offensive line. The selections of right guard David DeCastro and left tackle Mike Adams with their first two picks in the NFL Draft will not pay immediate dividends as DeCastro blew out his knee in the team’s third preseason game, but Adams will battle Trai Essex for the starting job at left tackle and will provide much needed depth.

Meanwhile, Ramon Foster is slotted back in at right guard. He’s started 26 games in his first three seasons with the Steelers, plus three playoff games during their Super Bowl run two seasons ago, so there’s some familiarity there. Last year’s second-round pick Marcus Gilbert is back at right tackle with a year of experience under his belt, while Willie Colon is finally healthy and will start at left guard, further solidifying the offensive line next to stud center Maurkice Pouncey. Ben Roethlisberger should have much more time in the pocket this season, and we all know what Big Ben is capable of when he has time in the pocket.

The lack of running back depth is a little bit of a concern for the Steelers, but Pittsburgh has consistently shown the ability to perform well through injuries in past seasons, so the concern is a minor one. Pittsburgh also has a concern of their own on defense with linebacker James Harrison expected to miss the start of the season after undergoing arthroscopic knee surgery, but in comparison to the blow that the Ravens suffered with Suggs, the Steelers come out on the winning end.

Here’s how I see the AFC North breaking down:
1.    Pittsburgh (10-6) – Super Bowl contender. Lack of depth could prove costly if injuries arise.
2.    Baltimore (9-7) – Elite team with an absolutely brutal schedule.
3.    Cincinnati (7-9) – Slight regression, and they won’t be able to prey on easy schedule this season.
4.    Cleveland (4-12) – In the running for the No. 1 overall pick next April.

In respect to the odds to win the division, I think Pittsburgh is the only bet here. As outlined earlier, the Steelers have some distinct advantages over the Ravens heading into this season, making them more likely to win the AFC North.  I’d say that the Steelers probability of winning the AFC North is somewhere in the 50-60% range, making them worth a small wager at +140 at

Comments (13)

  1. I can’t see the Browns with more than 2 wins this year. With rookies at the top 2 positions, and with so little else to offer in terms of weapons around those 2 rookies, their offense is in loads of trouble (see St. Louis Rams). Their defense is decent, but no where close to great.

    I see Baltimore finishing 12-4 again. I know their schedule is brutal, but they are a great team. Their ability to win those big games is why they were one drop away from the Super Bowl. I don’t trust Flacco, but he’s smart enough to not lose games for them. And also, Ray Rice is going to have a MONSTER year!!

    Pittsburgh will suffer a little early with Wallace missing the entire camp and their O-line needing more time to sync up… but look for a prolonged winning streak in the second half of the year as they really start to get (and get Mendenhall back after week 4).

    As for Cincy, I’m in total agreement with your assessment. They will face a much tougher schedule after making the playoffs. I see them more as the Tampa Bay team of a few years ago that made the playoffs, only to free fall last year. I don’t believe that they record will be as bad as Tampa’s was, but 7-9 or 6-10 is bang on!

    • Cinci is a complete fraud. Dalton has been terrible in preseason and BJGE isn’t much of a back.

  2. Already locked in Pittsburgh at +130. Glad you agree.

  3. dafaefeafefeawfeaw

  4. I see the Ravens with a clear edge over the Steelers.

    The steelers lost a lot of starters on the defensive side of the ball and the aging factor is a wash IMO between these two teams.

    Pitt has running back issues, for a running team. Balt should be solid offensively barring injuries.

    Can’t wait to see these teams play against each other this year. They are always the most exciting regular season games on the year.

    Looking forward to the next division breakdown pizzola!

    • Think you’re overestimating the extent to which the Steelers are a running team. When Haley was the OC in ARI they were top 3 in pass attempts both years. Roethlisberger and that young receiving trio are the core of this offense, and the coaching staff knows it.

      • Totally agree with this. The Steelers have not been a running team since Bettis left.

        • It’s a good assessment. The downgrade to Redman isn’t as bad since opposing Ds have to respect the pass against PIT.


  6. So many more reputable online books out there, why would anyone play at SMH

  7. You know, last year, everyone wrote off the Bengals at the beginning of the year and they made the playoffs. Now they go out and draft really well, while the Steelers lose DeCastro and the Ravens have an aging defence and Suggs is out.

    All Cinci has to do is beat up on Cleveland and split their games with the Steelers and Ravens and they are 4-2 against the division. That’s not far off. And with a broken up O-line in Pittsburgh… I bet Baby Ben spends a lot of time on his back. And Flacco…? /shrug, I don’t think he’s any better or worse than Dalton.

    That being said, the Bengals haven’t had a back-to-back winning season since ’81-’82. Perhaps this is the year all bets are off. Zimmer has the D fired up and Cinci is a young, dynamic team.

    But to write them off… is just crazy.

    WHO DEY!

  8. v. good. i stick glue for next blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *