Learning from Joakim Noah

Yesterday I wrote about Joakim Noah. My piece went up before he was handed a $50,000 fine from the NBA and before Kevin Arnovitz posted a one-on-one Q&A with him that you have to read if you haven’t already. No seriously, if you’re reading this without having read Arnovitz’s piece, stop and go there now.

A couple of days removed from Noah using that ugly word, two things have happened as a result of that TrueHoop post: Noah comes out of this looking more like the open-minded thinker we thought he was rather than another ignorant, intolerant basketball player and we’ve been given another reminder of how long it’s going to take before we get to a point where words like “faggot” are not spoken without thought or consequence. Reading Arnovitz’s TrueHoop post made me feel relieved and disheartened all at the same time.

Noah told Arnovitz that this “isn’t who he is,” and when you hear a little more about Noah’s life and family, it’s easy to believe him. This is the man who was, per the words of his Swedish mother, raised in a “multicultural and multiracial” family. His mother’s best friend was a gay man, whom a young Noah affectionately called “Mom.” When he uses a gay slur in reaction to an obnoxious, profane fan, of course we don’t want to believe that he meant it. We want to believe that Noah, without thought and most likely without literal meaning, used a word he’s had tossed around him enough times to have it weasel its way into his vocabulary.

So Noah didn’t mean to offend people because he doesn’t hate gay people. That’s great news, but … we’ve got to get this to stop. How? We can fine Noah and Kobe and whoever else and, sure, losing money always stings. Maybe it will even make them think twice so that in addition to not losing more money, they’ve realized hurting people isn’t cool. But how do we eliminate this word being used in every day conversation? I don’t have an answer for this, but I do believe continuing the dialogue is the most important step to change.

The conversation that took place between Arnovtiz, an openly gay sportswriter, and Noah, a man facing public criticism and likely some personal contemplation as well, was an important one. It was important for us as a collective readership to learn about Noah’s family and upbringing and to hear him say he’s disappointed in himself and that this isn’t who he is. To hear that despite this word being thrown around by another NBA player, to know that a current player doesn’t feel an NBA locker room is homophobic (echoing on the thoughts of Charles Barkley). It was important for those in the gay community to hear Arnovitz explain to Noah that he did indeed offend people with the slur and it was important for Noah to look into the eyes of someone who could explain this better than a sea of reporters tossing out questions in a crowded media scrum could.

I don’t believe that Noah is homophobic. I believe him when he says he didn’t mean to hurt people. I believe he used a word he wishes he could take back, a word that is tossed around far too often by people who are not intending to hurt those that it does indeed hurt. I wish this wasn’t the case, that this word could disappear, but that is going to take time. Time and conversations and lessons that are hard ones to have to learn, especially when learning them under the spotlight.

When Noah said that word, the disappointment was almost two-fold, because of the things we know about his character and personality. You don’t want to believe someone like Noah would say it, but he did. Here’s hoping he doesn’t use it again. Here’s also hoping that others who use the word — without regard, without concern, without thinking — will hesitate.

The conversation between Arnovitz and Noah was one that doesn’t happen often between reporter and athlete. It’s unfortunate that this conversation had to happen at all, but as we move forward toward a day where this won’t happen, there are lessons to be learned and conversations to be had. Today I’m thankful that Noah agreed to have this conversation rather than simply saying he was sorry and moving on. I’m also especially thankful that our sport has someone with a voice as unique, strong and talented as Kevin Arnovitz to keep these conversations going, even as I look forward to the day when they won’t be necessary.

Comments (14)

  1. This article is seriously retarded. I’m sorry, but please stop. Just stop.

  2. I’m seeing -something- retarded here, but it isn’t this article.

  3. I think by using these words you guys are missing the whole point of these articles.. People are mean on the internets. lol

  4. one of the best discussions I’ve ever seen on the use of that word was on an episode of the series Louie…which is a weird place to find it since Louis CK uses the word fairly often in his act. But it’s a scene with a poker game of fellow comedians and one of them is gay…won’t try and recreate it here, but seek it out.

  5. think the scene is on funnyordie.com, can’t link to it…work firewall

  6. This article, ugh.

    That article on Noah by Kevin, I’ll sum it up very simply:

    Noah: That’s not who I am.
    Kevin Yeah, that’s why I was disappointed. I expected more from you.
    Noah: That’s not who I am.
    Kevin: Yeah, didn’t think you were. But how so?
    Noah: I’ve been around gay people. Called a gay dude mom. That’s not who I am
    Kevin: Well, then, tell us who you are.
    Noah: That’s not who I am.

    Meaningless if you tell me. All he said was “That’s not who I am”.

    Which is cool and all, just let the dude pay his fine and chill. But it’s silly to try to defend him.

  7. There are stories worth writing about, and then there are stories worth writing about:

    http://sports.yahoo.com/tennis/blog/busted_racquet/post/Frenchwoman-Razzano-competes-eight-days-after-de?urn=ten-wp872

  8. Agreed with ari there… You’re very sweet Holly, but you just don’t get it (like easily offensed gay men don’t get it): a slur is a slur. It expresses hate.

    In most cases, it expresses unbiased hate (like Noah saying “faggot” as a general insult, not against gay people), sometimes, it expresses very specific hate (like Hitler saying “faggot”).

    If you erase the word, it doesn’t erase the hate…. It will find another way, another word to get through… Censorship and PC just makes homophobic and racist people harder to point out.

    ‘Cuz a homophobic person nowadays wont say “faggot”… You can be homophobic by saying “homosexual”,it just depends on HOW you say it and WHY.

    I mean: wasn’t “gay” tought as a slur before the LGBT world took it as its own?

    Words don’t have any meaning except those that the person who used them intended them to have to. Being held responsible for the way people react to what you say seems pretty ridiculous to me. It’s THEIR reaction. Words have a different meaning to every person.

    Well, it seems like a rant-ful topic for me….

  9. I think this whole gay slur kerfuffle has been blown out of proportion. I mean, sheesh, no one is perfect. I guess it must suck being in the NBA if you’re going to be hounded for one tiny mistake. Well, you know what? Fag, retard, wow, what’s going to happen to me now?

  10. @Vesper

    I’m sorry, how is that any worth writing about?
    Who gives a shit about this girl?

    Great for her, who cares?

    In the end, the meaning of an slur is much more worth writing about than a courageous woman, because it can spur debate, and then progress, while the only thing someone can say about your link is “wow! how courageous”….

    Seems as pointless to me as “wow! is it rainy today!” or “torture is bad” kind of article…. Al you want to say is “yeah, so what?”

    a lot of people go to work the next day after a death, and no-one writes about them…. And they’re not playing a silly game (Imean: tennis? really?) for 2 and a half hour before getting home… They’re working 50 hours of a boring job….

    Is that worth writing about?
    Not even, because everyone agrees on that… What worth is there in a discussion when everyone agrees.

  11. Damn +1 for Breyzh, u expressed exactly how feel about the word faggot and the way that I used it, when I use it. I don’t go around saying it all the time to everyone but when i do its just like any other other insult there’s no deeper meaning behind it.

  12. Im a serious Christian and I don’t take as a huge offense when half the people around me use “Jesus Christ” as a swear word.

    However I am trying to do my best to stop using gay slurs because I know hearing my Saviour name in vain does still sting a little. I don’t want to be ignorantly doing that to anyone else who holds homosexuality as a high value.

    If pointing out the bad way NBA stars use these phrases is the best way to stop the word use, then so be it.

    However I still agree with Breyzh’s sentiments that the heart of what is said means far more then the word itself.

  13. this article is gay.

  14. Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this web site daily, this web page is truly nice and the people are actually sharing fastidious thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *